1st Choice Cat Food Reviews

Choosing the right food for your cat can be a daunting task. What makes a good cat food? Whose reviews can you trust? Here at CatFoodDB, we generate our brand reviews using our own custom algorithm from the data provided straight from the manufacturer - the product ingredient lists and its published guaranteed analysis. You can find more details about how we do this here: CatFoodDB's Review Process.

Is 1st Choice good for cats? Based on our analysis of 19 unique 1st Choice cat food products, 1st Choice is a below average overall cat food brand when compared to other products in our database.

Of these 19 1st Choice products we reviewed:

• 1 product (5.3%) contains significantly fewer carbs than average.
• 2 products (10.5%) contain no questionable products or fillers. Conversely, this also means that the majority of the products reviewed contain at least one undesirable ingredient. You can click on each product's individual review for more information.
• 18 products (94.7%) list a high-quality protein as their first ingredient.

Based on our analysis of 7 unique 1st Choice wet (canned) cat food products, 1st Choice is a below average wet cat food brand when compared to similar products in our database.

CatFoodDB's Top 3 1st Choice Wet Cat Foods

Product

Details

Ratings

1st Choice Sterilized

Primary Proteins: chicken, pork & salmon

Allergens: seafood

Product Highlights:

• First ingredient is a quality protein.

Ingredients:

Nutrition:

Full CatFoodDB Review

---

1st Choice Healthy Start

Primary Proteins: chicken, pork & salmon

Allergens: seafood

Product Highlights:

• First ingredient is a quality protein.

• Contains significantly fewer carbs than average.

Ingredients:

Nutrition:

Full CatFoodDB Review

---

1st Choice Indoor Vitality

Primary Proteins: chicken, pork & salmon

Allergens: seafood

Product Highlights:

• First ingredient is a quality protein.

Ingredients:

Nutrition:

Full CatFoodDB Review

---

Based on our analysis of 12 1st Choice dry (kibble) cat food products, 1st Choice is an average dry cat food brand when compared to similar products in our database. Note that dry foods will almost always rank lower than their wet food counterparts due to the higher carbohydrate content found in most dry pet food.

CatFoodDB's Top 3 1st Choice Dry Cat Foods

Product

Details

Ratings

1st Choice Derma (Dry)

Primary Proteins: salmon & menhaden fish

Allergens: seafood & dairy

Product Highlights:

• First ingredient is a quality protein.

• Contains no questionable ingredients or fillers.

Ingredients:

Nutrition:

Full CatFoodDB Review

---

1st Choice Optimal Growth (Dry)

Primary Proteins: cod & menhaden fish

Allergens: seafood & dairy

Product Highlights:

• First ingredient is a quality protein.

• Contains no questionable ingredients or fillers.

Ingredients:

Nutrition:

Full CatFoodDB Review

---

1st Choice Urinary Health (Dry)

Primary Proteins: chicken

Allergens: None

Product Highlights:

• First ingredient is a quality protein.

Ingredients:

Nutrition:

Full CatFoodDB Review

---

At our last check, 1st Choice did not have any kitten foods available for review.